NEWS

ONKN on proposal for fisheries act: Can change society significantly

Consultation statement from Oceans North Kalaallit Nunaat regarding the Fisheries Act.

“It has the potential to significantly change the entire Greenlandic society.” says Executive Director Jenseeraq Poulsen after Oceans North Kalaallit Nunaat’s review of the proposal for the new Fisheries Act. In this regard, he points to several potential consequences of the Fisheries Act in its current form, where especially dinghy fishers may be affected, which may mean a change in settlement patterns.

The proposal for the Fisheries Act covers a broad spectrum of the fishing industry, and it contains many positive measures that will contribute to a more biologically sustainable fishery. However, Oceans North Kalaallit Nunaat has chosen to focus on especially two themes in the Act which are of concern: the model for Individual Transferrable Quotas (ITQ) in the coastal fishery, as well as management principles according to international conventions and bilateral agreements that Greenland has joined.

Oceans North Kalaallit Nunaat recommends that the Fisheries Act will also include the precautionary principle, an ecosystem-based approach to fisheries management, as well as management of the impacts of climate change. Furthermore, the ITQ model should include safeguards that ensure the survival of sustainable small-scale fisheries.

Consequences of IOK

The purpose of the Fisheries Act is to optimize the economy in the fishery. In general, Oceans North Kalaallit Nunaat does not dispute that a society wish to maximize the income from its resources. However, the purely economic approach in the Fisheries Act, as we read it, gives cause for concern. It overlooks the wider socio-economic implications for the dinghy fishers. The presented ITQ model will particularly affect the section of the dinghy fishers who combine small-scale fishing with hunting. The model used in the transition to ITQ will favor those fishers who happen to have fished the most in the recent period. At the same time, it will marginalize the fishers who have had a more equal distribution in their profession between fishing and hunting. They will thus be squeezed out of the system and lose a vital part of their income. In addition to the fact that this system will be perceived as unfair, it will also have a negative impact on the economy of many local communities where both private individuals and companies depend on hunting and fishing.

In Oceans North Kalaallit Nunaat, we are very concerned that the consequence of the proposal for the Fisheries Act in its current form may mean a changed settlement pattern, especially in North Greenland. Experiences from other countries show that the introduction of ITQ models without regard to socio-economic conditions will result in the depopulation of smaller local communities. Without built-in safeguards in an ITQ system, which ensure that local communities can still employ the socio-economically sustainable small-scale fishers and hunters, this will threaten the livelihoods of local communities.

We at Oceans North Kalaallit Nunaat question whether the increased national economic output is sufficient to offset the social and cultural costs of this development. Fishery is the main industry of Greenland, and it will therefore affect the entire Greenlandic society. Considering this challenge, we call for a more proactive approach with an ITQ system that considers the wider consequences and ensures sustainable development for all parties involved.

“The Fisheries Act is not only about sustainable use of the resource in its strict sense. The purpose of the Fisheries Act should be to ensure sustainable development, both biologically, economically, socially, and culturally. What we are really talking about is how we would like Greenlandic society to be in the future.” says Jenseeraq Poulsen.

Shortcomings in management principles

We in Oceans North Kalaallit Nunaat also believe that the proposal for the Fisheries Act has shortcomings in relation to modern management principles in fisheries management and nature management. We are concerned that the purpose, scope, definitions and regulatory provisions do not sufficiently include modern principles within fisheries management. Principles that are well described in international law and politics, some of which are already described in some of Naalakkersuisut’s strategies – For example, Greenland’s Biodiversity Strategy 2023 and the current work with the UN’s Global Goals for Sustainable Development. Likewise with the management principles in the adopted convention from the Northwest Atlantic Fisheries Commission (NAFO).

Failure to include modern management principles, such as the precautionary principle, an ecosystem-based approach and management of the impacts of climate change, raises concerns about the Act’s ability to ensure the long-term sustainability of fish populations.

“We look forward to the continued adaptation of the new Fisheries Act, because we really need it. We just have to ensure that the Act is modern and reflects the changed reality of climate change and biodiversity crises, which create additional pressures.” says Jenseeraq Poulsen.

Oceans North Kalaallit Nunaat recommends

In addition to the fact that scientific advice should be complied with under the new Fisheries Act, we in Oceans North Kalaallit Nunaat recommend that the Fisheries Act, as a minimum, will contain additional management principles and approaches such as:

  • The precautionary principle
  • Ecosystem-based approach to fisheries management
  • Management of the impacts of climate change

We also propose that safeguards should be built into the ITQ model, which ensure the survival of socio-economically sustainable small-scale fisheries. From Oceans North Kalaallit Nunaat, we would like to urge Naalakkersuisut and Inatsisartut to carefully consider and address the concerns raised before adopting the Fisheries Act in its final form.

Oceans North Kalaallit Nunaat’s consultation statement can be read in full HERE.

 

For media inquiries or further information please contact:

Jenseeraq Poulsen

Executive Director, Oceans North Kalaallit Nunaat

jenseeraq@oceansnorth.gl

+299 483467

Latest news

Billede1
Press release

Grønlandsk miljøorganisation: Pause i udnyttelsespligten kræver en større kvotesænkning

Read More →
849194697_1088107404108253_7392592432028669193_n
Press release

On 15 October, Inatsisartut voted to move towards a pause on deep-sea mining in Greenland’s waters

Read More →
Billede1
Press release

Nunatsinni avatangiisit pillugit suliniaqatigiiffik: Pisassiissutinik atuinissamut pisussaaffiup unitsikkallarneqarnerani pisassiissutit annertunerusumik ikilisinneqartariaqarput

Read More →
25.11.20_BBCSW_DAY1_X100_KIRILENKO_208
ONKN in the press

New Film Release: The Arctic Edge – Navigating change in the Arctic waters of Greenland

Read More →
Press photo
Press release

Nordic environmental organisations raise concerns over unsustainable fisheries ahead of COP17

Read More →
Screenshot ON deep sea mining animation
Press release

Article on deep-sea mining from 2024

Read More →
Scroll to Top